A Christmas Carol

Forced into factory work at age 12 to repay his father's debt, Charles Dickens' early hardship etched into him a profound understanding of the human cost of upheaval.

Dec 22, 2024

Finding Ourselves in the Ghosts of Christmas Past

Thanks for stopping by Compass Star Wordsmith. If you’ve been enjoying the stories I share here—uncovering old recipes, talking about music, diving into the art of craft, or connecting history’s threads to our lives today—I’d love your support. Subscribing is free and easy, but stepping up as a paid subscriber makes a real impact. Substack’s model ensures that your support doesn’t just keep me going—it helps creators across the board. All of my revenue from Substack is re-invested in Substack creators. And hey, even a like or a share goes a long way in spreading the word and growing this community. Let’s keep building something meaningful together.

If music speaks to you, you might’ve seen some of my work over at mxdwn.com. There, I dig into albums that make a mark and sit down with the artists that make the music to hear their stories firsthand. Those conversations—the ones where music makers open up about their craft, their struggles, and their inspirations—are what fuel so much of my writing here, too. On Compass Star Wordsmith, I take it a step further, weaving those moments into broader stories about the sounds, tastes, and experiences that shape our lives. If that resonates with you, join me on both platforms. Let’s keep finding the connections that make it all worth it.

Leave a comment

Finding Ourselves in the Ghosts of Christmas Past

As a Gen-Xer, I’ve always been drawn to the cultural artifacts that stand as touchstones—moments when food, music, art, craft, and history aligned to crystallize a collective experience. Works like A Christmas Carol, The Wizard of Oz and A Charlie Brown Christmas once anchored entire generations, shaping how they saw the world, themselves, and their dreams for the future. Shown just once a year on one of three channels, they created bridges to unknown perspectives, opening doors to places we did not know existed. Leaving those places to return to reality was the worst. Finding them lost and out of touch now cuts new wounds and picks old scabs of neglected innocence and forgotten childhoods.

These weren’t just stories; they were shared traditions—holiday feasts that brought families together, communal caroling in frosty neighborhoods, handwritten cards exchanged as tokens of love, or hand-carved gifts made with care—woven into the fabric of societal memory. Today, however, those cultural waypoints seem to flicker like the final embers of a dying fire. The universal moments they once offered now feel as distant as an old phonograph record gathering dust.

Maybe that’s why the nihilism of Gen-X touchstones—Devo’s post-industrial sarcasm, Black Sabbath’s doomy disillusionment, Rush’s philosophical skepticism, and Led Zeppelin’s mystical wanderings—still resonates so deeply. These weren’t just expressions of rebellion; they reflected a world where optimism felt misplaced and where the shared cultural landmarks of the past were dissolving into distant echoes. Yet even within that disillusionment, there was a found likeness—a sense that in acknowledging the cracks in the world, we could discover common bonds and envision a camaraderie beyond our alienation. This camaraderie often transcended barriers of race and gender, forming connections rooted in mutual disaffection and a collective search for authenticity. In a generation shaped by the collapse of idealism and the rise of skepticism, these bonds were forged not by shared appearances but by shared experiences: a knowing nod at a concert, the swapping of tapes or vinyl, or simply the unspoken understanding that the world was flawed, but that we could find meaning together in its imperfections.

In that same spirit, I approach A Christmas Carol not just as a beloved holiday tale but as a mirror to our fractured cultural landscape. Dickens’s story, rooted in the experiential reality of Victorian London, reminds us of a time when the five elements of culture—food shared around simple but meaningful holiday meals, music sung not through headphones but through voices in harmony, the art of storytelling passed on by candlelight, the craft of hand-knitted stockings or lovingly decorated trees, and the history of traditions built to unite generations—formed a unified vision of who we were and who we could be.

These traditions, once so central, have slowly faded, replaced by convenience and commercialization. We no longer gather to cook recipes passed down through generations; instead, we order in. Caroling has been replaced by curated playlists. Handwritten notes and handcrafted gifts now feel like relics of a time when effort and intention carried meaning. And yet, the longing for these connections remains, as does the potential for us to rediscover them.

Through this lens, A Christmas Carol isn’t just a holiday story. It’s an invitation. It invites us to reflect on the shared experiences we’ve lost and consider how to breathe life into them again. It reminds us that our cultural landmarks—whether Dickensian or Gen-X, nostalgic or nihilistic—carry echoes of what we’ve always longed for: a likeness found in each other, a common bond forged in shared experience, and the potential for future camaraderie.

The challenge before us is not just to remember those echoes but to act on them. To gather again, to create again, to connect again. Culture, in its full complexity, is our anchor in a world that often feels adrift. Let’s revisit the touchstones—in the kitchen, in song, in art, in craft, and in storytelling—and see what we can build together for the next generation. After all, the best mixtapes always start with a deep cut.

The Dickensian Shadow

Charles Dickens’s childhood was marked by upheaval and betrayal. His father, John Dickens, was a “jovial opportunist with no money sense,” whose chronic debt eventually landed him in Marshalsea Debtors’ Prison. At just twelve years old, young Charles was forced to leave school and work in a boot-blacking factory, scraping labels off bottles to keep his family afloat. The factory’s harsh conditions were not just physically grueling but emotionally scarring, searing into Dickens a vivid understanding of class, labor, and the brutal indifference of society. For a boy with dreams of education, the experience was a devastating detour.

What cut more deeply than the factory’s drudgery, however, was his mother’s insistence that Charles remain there even after his father’s release. To Dickens, this was an unforgivable act of pragmatism, a prioritization of survival over aspiration. “It is good to be children sometimes,” he would later write, “and never better than at Christmas, when its mighty Founder was a child Himself.” This wistful observation underscores the loss Dickens felt—a childhood cut short by the weight of adult responsibilities. That betrayal became a recurring theme in his work: children forced to carry burdens far beyond their years and the harsh systems that demanded this sacrifice.

Gen X and the Weight of Responsibility

For many in Gen X, Dickens’s narrative resonates deeply. They, too, grew up in a world that required them to adapt to fractured systems and fend for themselves at a young age. They were the first generation of latchkey kids, often left alone after school while their parents worked long hours, pursued personal ambitions, or struggled to navigate single parenthood. For those raised by single mothers, there was a profound duality: a deep admiration for their mothers’ sacrifices paired with an unspoken resentment for the childhood freedoms they had to forfeit. Like Dickens, many Gen Xers grew up feeling the weight of adult responsibilities while still children. Their sacrifices—whether emotional, financial, or both—shaped their worldview, instilling in them a pragmatism that would later define their generation.

But if Gen X was pragmatic, it was also quietly rebellious. Chaos was a constant presence in their lives, and they learned to navigate it with a resourcefulness born of necessity. The flickering CRT screens of their solitary afternoons were both a comfort and a mirror, reflecting the disconnection they felt within their fractured families. MTV became a lifeline, offering a kaleidoscope of music videos that were as much about escape as they were about identity. Madonna’s bold defiance, Metallica’s brooding aggression, and the sharp lyricism of Public Enemy provided not just a soundtrack but a framework for resistance. MTV was more than entertainment; it was a cultural touchstone that shaped a generation hungry for something authentic.

The Rebellion of Chaos

The Rebellion of Chaos wasn’t just an aesthetic; it was a worldview, a primal scream against the disintegration of stability and meaning. Maybe that’s why the nihilism of Gen-X touchstones—Devo’s post-industrial sarcasm, Black Sabbath’s doomy disillusionment, Rush’s philosophical skepticism, and Led Zeppelin’s mystical wanderings—still resonates so deeply. These artists didn’t simply reject the system; they painted its collapse in vivid, chaotic colors, echoing the turbulence of a generation whose rites of passage were shadowed by economic stagnation, nuclear anxiety, and the slow-motion implosion of institutional trust.

The music wasn’t merely rebellion for rebellion’s sake. It reflected a world where optimism felt not just misplaced but naive, where the shared cultural landmarks of the past—vinyl, local radio, the shared family stereo—were dissolving into distant echoes. As the music medium fragmented into an accelerating cycle of disposability—vinyl to 8-track to cassette to CD to digital—the sense of permanence and shared experience gave way to the isolating churn of consumption. Yet even within this disillusionment, Gen-X found something profound: a shared likeness, a camaraderie forged not in hope but in the acceptance of chaos.

In acknowledging the cracks in the world, these songs and their listeners dared to find beauty, humor, and solidarity amidst the rubble. If the system was destined to fail, at least we could laugh at its absurdity, headbang through its downfall, and, in the end, discover one another in the noise. It was rebellion, yes, but it was also resilience—the chaos was ours, and in it, we found meaning.

This camaraderie often transcended barriers of race and gender, forming connections rooted in mutual disaffection and a collective search for authenticity. In a generation shaped by the collapse of idealism and the rise of skepticism, these bonds were forged not by shared appearances but by shared experiences: a knowing smile at a concert, the passing of a joint, or simply the unspoken understanding that the world was flawed, but that we could find meaning together in its imperfections. Whether it was cruising from Sonic Burgers to Big ‘O Tires in built-out Mustangs with hot chicks riding shotgun or off-roading in 4x4 Blazers with gun racks and Stars n’ Bars or embracing the freedom to fly rainbow flags and smoke cigs on the quad, Gen-X built a uniquely inclusive yet paradoxically fractured community that reflected the contradictions of its time.

But that rebellion came at a cost. The unsupervised freedom that defined their youth also left scars. There were no smartphones to document their antics, no parental controls to monitor their decisions. Mischief ranged from harmless pranks to reckless behaviors that sometimes resulted in lasting consequences. Yet amidst the haze of beer-soaked weekends and smoke-filled dens, there was creativity. Garage bands formed, DIY skate ramps emerged, and graffiti claimed forgotten corners of the city. Even in its most destructive forms, chaos became a crucible for self-discovery.

By adulthood, Gen X had learned to wield chaos not as a destructive force but as a catalyst for change. Having grown up in a world that often prioritized appearances over substance, they became unflinching critics of hollow traditions. They embraced disruption not out of a desire to burn everything down but to demand authenticity. Whether through unconventional career paths, grassroots activism, or their often-disruptive political choices, Gen X sought to dismantle systems that no longer served them. The chaos they once survived now became a tool for transformation—a way to reject what was broken and rebuild something better.

The Shadows of the Past

The lessons of A Christmas Carol speak directly to the Gen X experience. The Ghost of Christmas Past forces Scrooge to confront his most vulnerable memories—the moments that shaped him but were too painful to face. “The shadows of the things that have been,” the ghost tells him, “they are what they are. Do not blame me!” The light of the ghost reveals more than nostalgia—it uncovers the jagged edges of wounds long ignored. Gen X, like Scrooge, often buried their hurt beneath layers of stoicism, believing survival required silence. But the ghost’s light exposes those buried truths, reminding them that the past, though painful, holds the key to understanding the present.

The ghost doesn’t stop with loneliness; it also shines on the ways their stoicism became a shield. Survival often required silence, and emotions were suppressed to avoid being seen as weak. The latchkey afternoons were spent mastering independence, but they also created emotional voids that were harder to fill in adulthood. Self-medicating tendencies—whether through work, drug use, or digital distractions—masked the grief of childhoods spent navigating adult responsibilities. The ghost forces Gen X to see how their coping mechanisms, while pragmatic, often kept them disconnected from deeper emotional truths.

Authenticity vs. Hypocrisy

Scrooge’s disdain for polite society’s superficiality resonates deeply with Gen X’s aversion to inauthenticity. When Scrooge dismisses the charitable solicitors—“If they would rather die, they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population”—it is not merely cruelty but a rejection of performative virtue. To Scrooge, polite society’s gestures of goodwill often felt hollow, masking deeper systemic failures. Gen X, similarly, grew up skeptical of anything that felt insincere. They saw through corporate jingles, hollow political promises, and shallow platitudes that sought to paper over real issues. Their rebellion wasn’t just about rejecting authority; it was about demanding something real.

Music, particularly grunge, became the soundtrack of this demand for authenticity. Nirvana’s “Come as You Are” and Pearl Jam’s “Alive” captured a generation’s longing for raw, unvarnished truth. Yet this hunger for realness didn’t emerge in a vacuum—it echoed the raw power of 70s hard rock bands like Led Zeppelin and Black Sabbath, whose heavy riffs and emotional depth first gave voice to rebellion and self-expression. The glossy bravado of 80s hair metal, from Mötley Crüe’s hedonistic anthems to Def Leppard’s polished rock epics, bridged the gap between primal force and stadium-ready spectacle. Meanwhile, the new wave scene of the 80s, led by acts like The Cure and Depeche Mode, channeled alienation into shimmering synths and introspective lyrics, reflecting a more cerebral pursuit of identity. Together, these movements paved the way for grunge’s unfiltered ethos, where skepticism extended to politics, rejecting traditional institutions and rituals that felt disconnected from lived realities. Like Scrooge, their cynicism was not without merit, but it also risked isolating them from the connections and community they craved.

The Present and Its Warnings

The Ghost of Christmas Present introduces Ignorance and Want, two gaunt figures representing societal neglect. “This boy is Ignorance. This girl is Want,” the ghost says. “Beware them both, and all of their degree, but most of all beware this boy, for on his brow I see that written which is Doom.” For Gen X, these figures symbolize the dual legacies they’ve passed on to their children. Ignorance reflects the blind spots created by their stoic survival—the refusal to fully examine the emotional toll of their upbringing. Want embodies the material and emotional struggles inherited by a generation navigating debt, inequality, and social disconnection. Much like Scrooge, Gen X must grapple with the realization that their silence and survival strategies, while necessary, may have inadvertently perpetuated cycles of disconnection in their families and society.

A Path to Redemption

Scrooge’s eventual reconciliation with the charitable solicitors and his nephew Fred mirrors Gen X’s growing recognition of the need to rebuild connections. “His wealth is of no use to him,” Fred says of his uncle. “He don’t do any good with it. He don’t make himself comfortable with it.” Fred’s warmth and persistent optimism offer a blueprint for Gen X: embracing vulnerability, seeking connection, and building a life that prioritizes meaning over materialism. The solicitors remind Gen X of the importance of stepping beyond cynicism to create tangible change.

The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come looms as the most chilling, its silence pressing upon Scrooge a final warning: that failing to change will lead to a legacy of emptiness. For Gen X, this ghost represents the risks of perpetuating cycles of disconnection. Without confronting the pain and silence of their past, they risk passing on a future defined by the same isolation and emotional gaps. Yet, like Scrooge, they carry the potential for transformation.

The Light of Christmas

Transformation, as Scrooge learns, requires action. Just as he bursts into the streets on Christmas morning with renewed joy, Gen X is finding ways to translate their introspection into tangible change. “Spirit,” Scrooge cries, “hear me! I am not the man I was.” They are building emotional safety in their families, prioritizing communication with their children, and challenging societal norms that perpetuate division. They’re embracing the chaotic change they once feared, understanding that progress is rarely tidy but always necessary.

Christmas, with its themes of renewal and shared humanity, offers the perfect moment for this realization. Scrooge’s promise—“I will honor Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year”—resonates as a call to action for a generation learning to balance pain with purpose. Gen X, like Scrooge, is discovering that the power to change the world begins within—and that the greatest gift is the willingness to grow, connect, and inspire.

And so, the city marches into its longest night. Beneath the cold and the cracks, the light endures—not because the world is ready to change, but because it must. Like Dickens’s London, this world teeters between despair and hope, and in its fragile balance lies the chance for something new. For Gen X, the lesson is clear: redemption is not a return to what was but a choice to serve the future while reckoning with the past. It’s a choice to demand better, even when the odds seem insurmountable. And, like Scrooge, they carry forward the promise of Christmas: the power to change the world begins within, and the greatest gift is sharing that power with others.

My Christmas Wish for you is just that. Change starts in the heart. Please share your love.

Merry Christmas,

Ric